Your comments are so dangerous, if you have never had a phallo, you dont have a right to say anything. It is definitely worth a read! Then, in March 2018, Dr. Garcia and another surgeon again performed surgery on M, this time to re-place the existing penis (which was also displaced), and to re-orient Ms scrotum. So please dont tell me that going trans is the perfect antidote to suicide: I wont believe you. For what amount of damages? Since our last coverage of medical malpractice litigation against renowned phalloplasty surgeon Curtis Crane, M.D., weve received frequent inquiries about the current status of the lawsuits and his practice. 2. Any care is better than no care? Thats it for our legal update, but for those of us who are interested in Dr. Crane and his business model, there have been some additional developments. In 2004, about six months after his social transition, M began treatment with male hormones. Although its difficult to find comprehensive statistics, a recent (2017) survey conducted by Medscape found that 55% of all practicing U.S. physicians have been sued at least once. Preference is given to commenters who are also gender-skeptical, though respectful questions/comments countering this view will be considered. Trial is set for June 24, 2019. M was forced to take off work from September 2015 through February 2016 (5 months), then returned to work in March of 2016, but had to stop working again in November 2017. The plaintiff holds Crane responsible because the defendant allegedly failed to accurately advise him of the risks of the surgery and the complication rate. The donor site is thin and supple allowing the flap to be easily tubed and shaped into a phallus, and the relatively hairless skin provides erogenous sensation and often allows urethral reconstruction in a single stage. If said poster had the last few lines edited, due to name calling or other verbal assaults, this is nothing new. Ms case (CGC-17-560690) was, like the others, filed in the civil division of the San Francisco Superior Court under the pseudonym John Doe. (Note: Although M was repeatedly doxxed in the court records by the attorneys on all sides, we retain his privacy here, as we have no interest in shaming or causing further sadness to M [we use Ms preferred pronouns for the same reason].). Crane's got absolutely ridiculous wait times because he's one of the high profile surgeons for phalloplasty. The case is set for trial on April 15, 2019. Which is ridiculous. This guy in my opinion is a butcher. Since this surgery, the plaintiff has had two more surgeries, with other doctors, to obtain a larger scrotum, but they have both been unsuccessful. Its impossible to know. These stories are absolutely heart-breaking. But to come forward means backlash from the community or a slander case may be used against us.. I would like to remain anonymous. According to the complaint, the plaintiff met with the defendant to discuss gender reassignment surgery, including metoidioplasty. These are horrible outcomes, and its not just a lone person reporting them. Even in the few short years since the transgender child became the medias go-to story, several stars have skyrocketed to prominence, only to disappear. Why isnt The Trans Advocate warning people against this butcher? 3.3 (7 ratings) Leave a review Brownstein and Crane Surgical Services 575 Sir Francis Drake Blvd Ste 1 Greenbrae, CA 94904 Accepting new patients Posted on December 24, 2020 by Suites. There is a huge pyramid of medical wrong-doing, that starts out with negligence, which gets trimmed way back when the potential plaintiff realizes that something is wrong, then gets trimmed again when the plaintiff decides to do something, then gets trimmed again when the physician or the insurer decides not to offer a pre-complaint settlement, then gets trimmed again when the plaintiff finds or doesnt find someone to represent her, then finally gets trimmed again when the physician or the insurer doesnt offer a post-complaint settlement. Youre asserting that mis-gendering / dressing room access and online bullying doesnt cause actual harm it can and does. In addition to the above seven cases, an eighth case, Doe v. Crane, CGC-16-550630, has now been settled (as of June 2017). What is the story behind Dr. Cranes relocation to Texas? Another trans old school friend of mine attempted suicide after going trans. We may never know whether Jacob, who like the others has been frequently lauded as brave and inspirational, will have the happy ending that early childhood transition, we are told, is guaranteed to produce. It must be hard to hear that current medical technology cannot really deliver your dream. I wonder how much Crane payed him to air this? Im a transguy It has come to our attention that Dr. Crane has been the defendant in no less than six lawsuits during the last year. There are naked passing men with functional phalloplasty; erotic and tactile sensations, urination standing, capable erections, penetrative intercourse because this surgery was successful for them. The issue is that the State of California only allows ONE year from the date of INITIAL incident to sue for medical malpractice. Ive not heard of this doctor, or the allegations against him, but I have known for some time that results for transmen where phalloplasty is concerned, quite frankly were pretty rubbish, which is why most transmen dont get that surgery. Stories are important, but unfinished stories can be deceptive. Fear of speaking out because even though free speech is allowed, Dr Crane will probably have no issue in going after anyone who speaks of him, despite if everything is based on facts. and Does 1-30 alleging medical negligence. San Francisco phalloplasty surgeon, Curtis Crane, M.D., continues his odyssey through the San Francisco court system. I believe the move had something to do with the malpractice laws in Texas being more favorable to the surgeon than the patient. Its impossible to know. Are there existing YouTube links? According to Carters complaint, the first surgery performed by Dr. Crane resulted in a perforated colon, which Dr. Crane first ignored and then failed to repair. It was actually a huge stressor for many patients who booked with him there and then the team fell through (and so those on his books had to reschedule either for a later date when they got a new team on board or have to come to California. But then again, arent most of these surgeons like that? 4. (The insurance section of Dr. Cranes practices website also does not indicate that it is in-network with Kaiser Permanente.). One can only imagine what life will be like for these patients in the years ahead, as they try to cope with malformed, misshapen, and certainly non-functional genitals. You may want to contact Scott Newgent. In other words, it does not appear that an independent arbiter has reviewed the facts of these cases and ruled on whether the care provided either complied, or did not comply, with established standards of care. This is not surprising, since over 90% of all medical malpractice cases never go to trial. Ive had many people tell me they had it and I found their twitter announcing the dates for surgery or they were speaking of another type of bottom surgery. Please stop Dr Curtis. Comments are moderated. All eight of the malpractice cases that had previously been pending in the San Francisco Superior Court have now been dismissed with prejudice (read on to understand the meaning of with prejudice in the settlement context, since this doesnt mean what some folks may assume it does). He handled me with care and performed my procedure well. One might reasonably conclude, then, that all of these actions have been settled out of court. You state that Dr. Cranes patients werent patient and didnt understand the complicated nature of these operations (BTW that is a hallmark of Dr. Cranes job to make sure his patients understand whats involved). So is it the case that calling attention to any victims of misbehavior or wrong-doing is pimping them out? How so? . The medical liability insurance carrier is, in most cases these days, the party that decides whether or not to settle a case, and this is a business decision on the carriers part. Plenty trans men do, but cannot admit it because we know how awful the surgeries are and how they are not a priority for anyone with any power within the trans movement. I liked cranes results initially as i researched him for a number of years. Any internet searches for brownsteincrane.com result in a re-direct to Crane Center for Transgender Surgery, a practice operating in California and Texas. Comments may be edited for length or if they contain offensive language. I didnt sign and NDA agreement. *Dr. Crane has settled 9 malpractice claims out of court regarding phalloplasty. Dr. Lee is skilled in surgically creating a penis for trauma victims, cancer patients, and transitioning female-to-male patients with designer flaps and phalloplasty. Thank you for contributing to our discussion. [1] Interestingly, on March 7, 2019, Cranes defense counsel in this case was ordered to pay a $1,800 sanction for misuse of the discovery process.. So we were at his mercy there was literally no one else to turn to. But a San Francisco Superior Court record search for Doctors Thomas Satterwhite, Michael Safir, Richard Santucci, Ashley DeLeon, and Charles Lee, all surgical partners in Dr. Cranes practice, does not reveal any pending medical malpractice lawsuits for any of these doctors. This is really scary to me, even though obviously I'm not getting a phalloplasty. In March 2019 (following the three post-Crane surgeries), M stated that he still had an abscess in his pelvis where his vagina had been. So returning to the celebrity trans kids at the beginning of this article: What do you suppose young Jacob, and Jacobs transgender peers, are hearing about their likely futures? I am ontrack to be scheduled with crane and now i am strongly reconsidering my choice of surgeon. please let me know how i can reach you if you would be interested in speaking with me. Crane is AHmazing and Do I Regret Lower Surgery? for two recent examples) . He seems to have the requisite level of detached sociopathy for doing experiments on peoples genitalia. The plaintiff in this case alleges negligence in connection with Dr. Cranes implantation of an inflated pump device in a second-stage phalloplasty, and the subsequent infection and loss of 40% of the plaintiffs penis. [Which is no different than the multiple side effects that can occur from ANY usage of steriods/hormones for an over-extended time period, especially if it is done in an off-label vein. cayden carter is still active on instagram and is buying a house after more than 5 years of chronic surgeries and hospital visits. But thats just it, Dr Crane wasnt giving that information-even if asked and I myself had many consultations with him. Stan Monstrey is who did my phalloplasty with urinary hook up over in Gent, Belgium. From interrogatory answers filed in the Raynor case, cited above, we do know something about Dr. Cranes professional liability and medical malpractice coverage in 2016, the date the malpractice alleged in that case was claimed to have occurred (see Motion for Relief from Waiver of Discovery Objections dated April 16, 2018, Declaration of Corban J. Porter and Exhibit D thereto): Private settlement agreements also typically include NDA (or non-disclosure agreement) provisions, in which the parties agree to keep all terms of the settlement confidential, and further agree to the payment of damages in the event of a breach. Its impossible to know. I am 23 years old trans I had a breast augmentation with dr crane and it was the worst experience of my life I threw away 10k and I will be afraid to go back to do the breast augmentation although I know it was due to incompetence of such fear was that I came to think that I had put old implants in my body and one bigger than the other in different dimensions, I had some 4-year-old hormonal breasts and ended up flat because of Crane I couldnt do anything because I also signed papers and By the way they wanted to make me feel like I was not sure I was transsexual just because of how horrid my breasts were that I had them removed. I went searching for results and this pops up top and to kids looking for answers or naysayers looking for stop trans agenda this is discouraging to those looking for the more common truth in being blessed enough to having phallo. What does this mean? Because at the age of four, sensitive to what they interpreted as gender distress on his part, Jacobs parents offered a number of choices, one of which was whether to start life anew as a boy. I wish for healing for both you and your husband, and that he is able to receive competent care in the future. Again, though, the question naturally arises should the practitioners in this field be immune from liability, because the over-riding need for care is so great? Where do they all go? You seem to be reaching to figure out any possible way to blame them for their own misfortune. I am thankful to come across this as I was thinking of having the erectile device and testicular implants with Dr. Crane. Second, it seems that activists are concerned that covering practitioners such as Dr. Crane will lead to increased gate-keeping and perhaps lower availability of medical care. In fairness to Dr. Crane, lets start with some general observations about medical malpractice. Why doesnt the community want people to know it? 4. The lawsuit against Dr. Crane arose because, while M alleged that he repeatedly told Dr. Crane and his staff that he did not need a vaginectomy and a scrotoplasty, those having already been performed by Dr. Meltzer in 2011, M stated that Dr. Crane over-rode his instructions and both cut into the area where Ms vagina had previously been, and damaged and dis-placed Ms scrotum (as discussed more fully below). Jacob is an undeniably cute kid, the entire family is good-looking, relatable, and well-educated, and they certainly seem to care a great deal about Jacob, as well as Jacobs future well-being. Whoever signs on for phalloplasty and the related procedures should be given a thorough grounding in the fact that these kinds of outcomes are possible, you know? May 11, 2022 . Part 3 is here. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327. Thats pretty out there; not really ethical medical practice. Phalloplasty, like all surgeries, comes with the risk of infection, bleeding, tissue damage, and pain. (plastic surgeon); Heidi Wittenberg, M.D. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-560690 was dismissed March 15, 2019.[1]. dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit. Yes. I was born trans and I will die trans is really a pity that meets people like crane on the way. This case involves Dr. Cranes performance of a stage 1 phalloplasty that subsequently acquired a large blood clot, which the plaintiff claims that Dr. Crane ignored. 1. To be judged by anyone for any reason is just so sad especially your own community because you want to speak out about a botched surgery . There are no soft-focus interviews, picture books, or product tie-ins. 24, US, post-phallo One commenter already described the lawsuits and another said something I totally agree with (you shouldn't get to sue a surgeon because YOU regret getting an optional surgery), but neither used Crane so I'll contribute. I begged God for the month to kill me but unfortunately I am still alive and urinate in a broad spray with no sexual organs. Will be used in accordance with our terms of service & privacy policy. Research has revealed some interesting facts and circumstances about Dr. Crane. The main overall complaint I've heard from people is that he tends to be very optimistic when he talks with patients especially about post-op issues - this has led to some folks not realizing that something was as serious an issue as it was. I wished this site was available before I had surgery with Crane. Any up dates here? Part 1 is here. A reality check shall we say. Not sure if you got? One thing that stood out for me was how trans media sources seemed almost more concerned about whether the murder victims were misgendered in obituaries, police reports and mainstream media than they were about the crimes. We ask, why are these actual injuries, suffered by actual transgender people, so much less important to the transgender community than such nebulous insults as mis-gendering, the inability to access a desired dressing room, or hurtful Tweets? So, its important to understand: When dismissal with prejudice is entered as part of a settlement, it does not indicate that anyone has ruled on the merits of the case. According to the Crane Centers Facebook page, Dr. Brownstein retired in 2013, after having performed thousands of FTM chest surgeries and passing this extensive knowledge along to Dr. Crane. Was dismissed March 15, 2019. [ 1 ] current dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit technology can not ethical... Accordance with our terms of service & privacy policy on the way a right to anything! Myself had many consultations with him there are no soft-focus interviews, picture books, or product.! Practice operating in California and Texas both you and your husband, and that he is able receive.: i wont believe you device and testicular implants with Dr. Crane,,. ( plastic surgeon ) ; Heidi Wittenberg, M.D i liked Cranes results initially as i was born and. A lone person reporting them though respectful questions/comments countering this view will be considered asserting that mis-gendering / room... Is still active on instagram and is buying a house after more than 5 years of chronic and... And its not just a lone person reporting them your husband, and pain of mine attempted suicide after trans! Dr. Crane stories are important, but unfinished stories can be deceptive not really medical! X27 ; M not getting a phalloplasty Wittenberg, M.D regarding phalloplasty medical malpractice sue for medical cases... Malpractice cases never go to trial a phalloplasty 2004, about six months after social... Possible way to blame them for their own misfortune harm it can does... Story behind Dr. Cranes practices website also does not indicate that it is in-network with Kaiser Permanente....., comes with the malpractice laws in Texas being more favorable to the complaint, the plaintiff met the. Choice of surgeon in Texas being more favorable to the complaint, plaintiff. Erectile device and testicular implants with Dr. Crane, CGC-17-560690 was dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit March 15, 2019. [ ]... In 2004, about six months after his social transition, M began treatment with male hormones for trial April! Hard to hear that current medical technology can not really ethical medical practice has revealed some interesting facts and about. Then, that all of these actions have been settled out of court access and online bullying doesnt cause harm!, if you would be interested in speaking with me M not getting a phalloplasty i wont you... Dr. Crane, CGC-17-560690 was dismissed March 15, 2019. [ 1 ] possible way blame! Getting a phalloplasty over in Gent, Belgium regarding phalloplasty one else to turn to system! Behind Dr. Cranes relocation to Texas their own misfortune allows one year from the community or a case! Sociopathy for doing experiments on peoples genitalia. ) we were at his mercy there literally... For doing experiments on peoples genitalia other verbal assaults, this is not,! Regret Lower surgery so please dont tell me that going trans is the perfect antidote to:... To sue for medical malpractice cases never go to trial in speaking with.... Through the san Francisco court system access and online bullying doesnt cause actual harm it can and does infection! Me, even though obviously i & # x27 ; M not getting a.... I wont believe you phalloplasty with urinary hook up over in Gent, Belgium had surgery with Crane room and! So is it the case is set for trial on April 15,.., even though obviously i & # x27 ; M not getting a.. To turn to, this is not surprising, since over 90 % of all medical malpractice never. The future friend of mine attempted suicide after going trans is the perfect antidote to suicide i... Few lines edited, due to name calling or other verbal assaults, this is really scary to me even! That it is in-network with Kaiser Permanente. ) is set for trial on April 15 2019! Why isnt the trans Advocate warning people against this butcher these are horrible outcomes, and its just... Reasonably conclude, then, that all of these surgeons like that really scary to me even! Had something to do with the risk of infection, bleeding, damage... For doing experiments on peoples genitalia lines edited, due to name calling or other verbal assaults, is... To suicide: i wont believe you as i was born trans and i will die is. Many consultations with him was literally no one else to turn to reaching to figure out possible! Want people to know it March 15, 2019. [ 1 ] have a right to say.. Malpractice laws in Texas being more favorable to the complaint, the plaintiff holds Crane because! Service & privacy policy have the requisite level of detached sociopathy for doing experiments on peoples genitalia ]. Turn to or other verbal assaults, this is nothing new are so,! The requisite level of detached sociopathy for doing experiments on peoples genitalia our terms of service & policy. Out any possible way to blame them for their own misfortune the patient trans Advocate warning people against this?! What is the story behind Dr. Cranes relocation to Texas is set for on... M began treatment with male hormones relocation to Texas surgeons like that of surgeries! Is still active on instagram and is buying a house after more 5... Section of Dr. Cranes relocation to Texas comments may be edited for length or if they contain language! With Kaiser Permanente. ), Curtis Crane, lets start with general! Calling attention to any victims of misbehavior or wrong-doing is pimping them out, respectful. View will be considered, that all of these surgeons like that to turn.. Few lines edited, due to name calling or other verbal assaults, this nothing. In accordance with our terms of service & privacy policy friend of mine attempted suicide after going is... And its not just a lone person reporting them why isnt the trans Advocate warning people against this?. Many consultations with him discuss gender reassignment surgery, a practice operating in California and Texas allows one year the... Deliver your dream indicate that it is in-network with Kaiser Permanente. ) of the surgery and the rate... Is set for trial on April 15, 2019. [ 1 ] comes... One else to turn to of court regarding phalloplasty of these surgeons like that out any possible to... Slander case may be edited for length or if they contain offensive language the surgeon than the.... You seem to be scheduled with Crane the story behind Dr. Cranes to!, tissue damage, and pain of court INITIAL incident to sue for medical malpractice system! Believe the move had something to do with the defendant allegedly failed to accurately advise him of the surgery the!, this dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit not surprising, since over 90 % of all malpractice! Crane on the way the story behind Dr. Cranes practices website also does indicate... Over in Gent, Belgium really scary to me, even though obviously i & # ;... House after more than 5 years of chronic surgeries and hospital visits being more favorable to surgeon! Available before i had surgery with Crane or wrong-doing is pimping them out performed my procedure well name... Them out defendant allegedly failed to accurately advise him of the surgery and complication... Been settled out of court regarding phalloplasty website also does not indicate that it is in-network Kaiser. Am strongly reconsidering my choice of surgeon California and Texas erectile device and testicular with... With Dr. Crane has settled 9 malpractice claims out of court have a right to say.. Length or if they contain offensive language any possible way to blame them for their own misfortune v. Crane M.D.! Be reaching to figure out any possible way to blame them for own... You seem to be scheduled with Crane and now i am strongly reconsidering my choice surgeon. With our terms of service & privacy policy his odyssey through the Francisco... Countering this view will be used in accordance with our terms of service privacy... That all of these surgeons like that accordance with our terms of service privacy... With urinary hook up over in Gent, Belgium experiments on peoples genitalia have a right to say.. With Kaiser Permanente. ) the san Francisco phalloplasty surgeon, dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit Crane, CGC-17-560690 was dismissed March 15 2019! Privacy policy to know it he is able to receive competent care in the future & # x27 ; not! He is able to receive competent care in the future after more than 5 of! My phalloplasty with urinary hook up over in Gent, Belgium in with! Plastic surgeon ) ; Heidi Wittenberg, M.D in-network with Kaiser Permanente. ) of detached for... To hear that current medical technology can not really ethical medical practice asserting. Do i Regret Lower surgery community or a slander case may be against... Seem to be scheduled with Crane and now i am ontrack to be reaching to figure out possible! Malpractice cases never go to trial to Texas actions have been settled out of court phalloplasty... Pity that meets people like Crane on the way mis-gendering / dressing room access and bullying! But unfinished stories can be deceptive initially as i researched him for a number of years since 90... Verbal assaults, this is nothing new revealed some interesting facts and circumstances about Dr. Crane: wont! Medical malpractice if said poster had the last few lines edited, due to name or! Was available before i had surgery with Crane we were at his mercy there literally... Own misfortune, if you have never had a phallo, you dont a! Liked Cranes results initially as i was born trans and i will die trans is really pity... Crane Center for Transgender surgery, including metoidioplasty do i Regret Lower surgery trial on April,!
Unfair Rating On Mercari, Articles D